Black locust, larch, chestnut and oak for raised beds: what the durability ratings really say

The Board Garden editorial teamUpdated 6 min read

Short answer

Black locust (Robinia) heartwood is the most durable of the four: the USDA rates it very resistant to decay and the European EN 350 scale puts it in class 1 to 2. Sweet chestnut is class 2, oak class 2 to 4 and larch only class 3 to 4, so larch is a moderately durable choice. In every species, sapwood counts as non-durable.

Planed black locust (Robinia) board showing yellow-brown heartwood grain, with a steel millimetre ruler along the bottom
Photo: Androstachys, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Key points

  • USDA Wood Handbook: black locust heartwood is very resistant to decay; white oaks and chestnut resistant; western larch and tamarack moderately resistant.
  • EN 350 durability classes (via France Bois Forêt): robinia DC1-DC2, sweet chestnut DC2, sessile oak DC2-DC4, larch DC3-DC4, Douglas fir DC3-DC4.
  • Sapwood of every species is excluded from natural durability: robinia has only 3 to 4 rings of it, larch up to about 1 in (2.5 cm).
  • In a Belgian lab test, mature robinia heartwood lost a median 0.3% of its mass to a decay fungus, against 38.5% for beech.
  • Ground contact is the hardest use: Swiss guidance (Lignum) advises against untreated wood for buried posts, whatever the species.

Black locust leads, larch is a middle option

Among the European-style woods often suggested for untreated raised beds, black locust (Robinia pseudoacacia) heartwood is the most durable, sweet chestnut and the white oaks come next, and larch sits in the middle band with Douglas fir. That ranking appears in both the American and European reference systems, even though they use different scales and test methods.

The USDA Wood Handbook (chapter 14, table 14-1) groups heartwood by average decay resistance. The European standard EN 350 assigns durability classes from DC1 (very durable) to DC5 (not durable), summarised for French species by France Bois Forêt. The table puts the two side by side.

Species USDA Wood Handbook rating EN 350 class (fungi) Heartwood treatability (EN 350, 1 treatable to 4 not treatable)
Black locust, robinia Very resistant DC1-DC2 4
Sweet chestnut Resistant (American chestnut) DC2 4
Oak Resistant (white oaks) DC2-DC4 (sessile oak) 4
Larch Moderately resistant (western larch, tamarack) DC3-DC4 4
Douglas fir Moderately resistant DC3-DC4 4
Scots pine Slightly or nonresistant (most pines) DC3-DC4 3-4
Spruce Slightly or nonresistant DC4 3-4
Beech Slightly or nonresistant DC5 1v (variable)

Two cautions apply. The USDA ratings are for North American species: “chestnut” there is American chestnut, not the European sweet chestnut (Castanea sativa), and the larches are western larch and tamarack rather than European larch (Larix decidua). And both systems rate heartwood only. For more species, see our wood durability ratings table.

Sapwood: the part that rots first in every species

Sapwood is the pale outer band of the trunk, and no durability rating applies to it. France Bois Forêt states that sapwood is excluded from natural durability, and the Swiss industry body Lignum classes the sapwood of all species as class 5, not durable. A board with a strip of sapwood along one edge will rot along that strip first, whatever the species name on the invoice.

This is where robinia has a practical advantage. The Wood Handbook describes black locust sapwood as narrow, and the Forêt Wallonne review by Pollet and colleagues gives it as only 3 to 4 growth rings. Larch sapwood is wider: the Handbook gives western larch sapwood as not more than about 1 in (2.5 cm), which on a 6 in (140 mm) board can still be a large share if the board was cut near the bark. When buying, look at the end grain and ask for heartwood-only boards (“purgé d’aubier” in French trade terms).

Black locust: what the lab tests show

Black locust heartwood owes its durability to extractives, polyphenols and flavonoids according to Pollet and colleagues, and it holds up very well in laboratory decay tests. Their review reports a test under CEN/TS 15083-1, in which durability class 1 means a mass loss below 5% and class 2 means 5 to 10%:

Sample Median mass loss with Coriolus versicolor Class
Robinia, mature heartwood 0.3% 1 (very durable)
Robinia, juvenile wood near the pith 5.8% 2 (durable)
Beech control, paired with mature heartwood 38.5% not durable
Beech control, paired with juvenile wood 32.5% not durable

The difference between mature and juvenile wood matters for buyers. Small-diameter robinia, or boards cut close to the pith, contain more juvenile wood and are a class lower. The Wood Handbook also notes that the locust borer, an insect, weakens black locust trees, which reduces the supply of large, clear logs.

Robinia has drawbacks as a building material. Pollet and colleagues describe the wood as fissile and “nerveux à très nerveux”, meaning it moves and distorts noticeably with changes in moisture. Boards can twist and check as they dry, so thicker sections and pre-drilled screw holes are sensible. University of Maryland Extension lists black locust among decay-resistant woods for beds and mentions locust as a rough-cut lumber available from local sawmills.

Larch: moderately durable, widely available in Europe

Larch is a softwood with resinous, dense heartwood that sits one to two classes below robinia. The Wood Handbook lists western larch and tamarack as moderately resistant; France Bois Forêt gives larch DC3 to DC4 under EN 350, the same as Douglas fir and maritime pine. The Handbook also notes that western larch splits easily and is subject to ring shake (separation along growth rings), which argues for pre-drilling near board ends.

In a raised bed, this means larch heartwood will outlast spruce, fir or beech by a wide margin, but it should not be expected to perform like robinia or chestnut in ground contact. The design choices that limit moisture count for more with larch: a gravel or open base so the bottom board is not sitting in wet soil, a top cap, and boards thick enough to tolerate some surface decay. Our page on board thickness shows how much stiffness a board loses when its face rots.

Chestnut and oak

Sweet chestnut is the European hardwood closest to robinia in durability: France Bois Forêt rates its heartwood DC2, and Pollet and colleagues describe both pedunculate oak and chestnut as “durable” in their comparison. The Wood Handbook places the white oaks in its resistant group, while France Bois Forêt gives sessile oak a wider DC2 to DC4 range, reflecting variation between trees.

Oak and chestnut have one practical constraint: tannins. A USDA Forest Products Laboratory report on fastener corrosion found oak extract to be the most corrosive of the four wood extracts it tested (oak, pine, locust, elm), with steel corroding at 279 µm per year in it against 74 µm per year in black locust extract. Oak beds need stainless-steel screws; see screws for raised beds.

Ground contact: what the use classes say

The bottom board of a raised bed touches soil, and European use-class guidance treats that as the most demanding situation for wood. Lignum defines use class 4 as wood in contact with soil or fresh water, with moisture content permanently above 20%. For buried posts it says untreated wood is not recommended (“déconseillé”), and for non-buried elements in class 4 it points to species of durability class 1, or 2 at a stretch.

Applied to a bed, this suggests:

  • Robinia heartwood is the one species in this group that meets the class 1 guidance and is suited to boards touching soil.
  • Chestnut and good oak heartwood (DC2) sit at the edge of it.
  • Larch and Douglas fir (DC3-DC4) are better kept off the soil, on a gravel strip or a sacrificial bottom board.

No source we found gives field service lives in years for these species as raised-bed walls. University of Arkansas Extension gives 3 to 5 years for untreated lumber and well past 10 years for cedar, which provides a rough frame. For a broader comparison including cedar, redwood and pine, see which wood is best for raised beds. If you are tempted to char larch to make it last longer, read what charring does to decay resistance first.

Method and limits

Ratings come from the USDA Wood Handbook (North American species, average heartwood behaviour), the France Bois Forêt summary of NF EN 350 (European species), the Pollet et al. review of robinia, and Lignum’s use-class sheet. Laboratory tests run for weeks to months on small samples; field performance depends on climate, soil, the share of sapwood and the build. We did not find field stake data in years for robinia, chestnut or larch in ground contact that we could verify, nor sourcing statistics or prices, so none are given.

Frequently asked questions

Is black locust better than cedar for raised beds?

On paper, yes. The USDA Wood Handbook places black locust heartwood in its very resistant group, above cedars, which are rated resistant. University of Arkansas Extension says a cedar bed may last well past 10 years. Black locust is harder to find as straight sawn boards and is fissile and prone to movement, so availability and workability are the usual limits.

How long does larch last in a raised bed?

No source we found gives a service life in years for larch beds. Its heartwood is rated moderately resistant by the USDA and DC3 to DC4 under EN 350, the same band as Douglas fir. That is a clear step below robinia or chestnut. Heartwood-only boards, a gravel or open base and 2x thickness all help it last.

What do EN 350 durability classes mean?

EN 350 is the European standard for the natural durability of wood. Against decay fungi it uses five classes: DC1 very durable, DC2 durable, DC3 moderately durable, DC4 slightly durable and DC5 not durable. The class applies to heartwood only; sapwood of all species is treated as not durable.

Can I use oak boards for a raised bed?

Yes, if they are heartwood. The USDA rates white oak heartwood resistant to decay, and EN 350 gives sessile oak DC2 to DC4, a wide range. Oak sapwood is not durable. Oak is also acidic and rich in tannins, which corrodes plain and galvanized steel quickly, so use stainless-steel screws.

Sources

  1. USDA Forest Service, Forest Products Laboratory (2021). Wood Handbook: Wood as an Engineering Material (FPL-GTR-282), chapters 2 and 14
  2. France Bois Forêt (2018). Fiche Comprendre C3 : La durabilité du bois (based on NF EN 350)
  3. Forêt Wallonne asbl (C. Pollet, K. Verheyen, J. Hébert, B. Jourez) (2013). Le bois de robinier faux-acacia : propriétés physiques, mécaniques et de durabilité naturelle, Forêt Wallonne n°126
  4. Lignum, Économie suisse du bois (2013). Classes d'emploi (use classes for wood)
  5. University of Maryland Extension (J. Traunfeld) (2026). Growing vegetables in raised beds
  6. University of Arkansas System Division of Agriculture, Cooperative Extension Service (2020). Raised-bed Gardening on a Budget
  7. USDA Forest Service, Forest Products Laboratory (S. Zelinka) (2013). Corrosion of fasteners in wood treated with newer wood preservatives (FPL-GTR-220)